I just replaced the rear springs on my 53 Manhattan, using NOS shackle and bushing sets I acquired from a dealer in antiquity. The rubber appear to be in new condition, and I could see no reason not to use them. Not sure one is going to find polyurethane in exactly the right shape/size. I also ended up re-using the U bolts (actually had some from a parts car too, and took the 4 best.) Was able to restore the threads with a die, and, again, could see no reason not to reuse. Seems that if they hadn't cracked after 200.000+ miles they probably didn't have any flaws. Thus far haven't seen any problems