My random thoughts on this topic:
My experience with radials from Coker Tire has been entirely positive. The car doesn't track every grove and crack in the road, and they ride just fine. I also had the car aligned at the same time which you should do what ever tires you end up getting.
New bias-ply tires probably work just fine also. I've never had new ones, I've only driven on old ones, and even old radials don't drive very well, in my experience.
As far as whitewall versus blackwall, that comes down to esthetics. What do YOU like? They both were available for cars back when our cars were new, so you can use either one, if you want to keep it all original.
I prefer the driving characteristics of Radials myself, and I have to DRIVE my car where ever I take it, and I take it on many trips. If you trailer it, then it doesn't matter.
Bias-ply's are cheaper and more original, too.
Hope this helps!