Jack, I proposed Cleveland as a meet site and would use one of a couple different possible hotels. One that comes to mind is the Holiday Inn at 77 and 480. Close to the train depot in Valley View, an easy shot to downtown for a baseball game, a boat ride, a visit to the Rock N Roll museum and not far also from the Crawford museum. The Nash club will be using this hotel next week for the national meet, which I will be attending.
I've been to Shipshewanna and it is bigger than you think. There are quite a few larger hotels nearby and it's an easy drive to any of the bigger Indiana cities.
By far, the best midwest meet site I've found has been Auburn, Indiana. There, the hotel sat in a cluster of hotels, restaurants and better shopping. Museums and attractions were minutes away. I'd like to see us back there one day soon.