SUCCESS!!! The new chain is on! I took the suggestion of heating the chain. I talked to a friend about it and he suggested putting the chain in the oven at 450 degrees for an hour. Even though this filled the kitchen with smoke and my wife wasn't too happy about that, it seems to have worked. With the heat, LOTS of lube, a little coercion from a small pry bar and light taps from a hammer, the sprocket slipped onto the shaft. I guess my wife wasn't too upset about the smoky kitchen. She was right there helping me put the chain on and seemed just as happy as I was when it finally went on. Thanks for the suggestions guys.